The Tax Problem With Online Sports Betting: Why the Rules Need to Change

Why recreational gamblers can face taxes despite breaking even, how inconsistent reporting complicates compliance, and why the current rules deserve reform.

The Perspective

Recreational gamblers can owe tax on money they never actually made, because federal law taxes winnings as income but only lets losses count as an itemized deduction, and several states don’t allow the losses at all.

In my view, a fairer system would tax documented net gambling gains before adjusted gross income, without letting losses offset unrelated income, and would give taxpayers standardized annual records to report from.

Online sports betting has grown into an enormous industry. According to the American Gaming Association, Americans wagered approximately $166.9 billion through commercial sportsbooks in 2025, generating nearly $17 billion in revenue for operators.

As a tax advisor, I’ve become increasingly concerned about how gambling is treated under our income tax system. The rules can create substantial tax liabilities for individuals who haven’t earned any actual profit, while the reporting requirements are complicated enough that many taxpayers don’t understand what they’re supposed to report.

I want to clarify that this article isn’t intended to advocate for or against gambling. I understand why policymakers might want to discourage it, including through unfavorable tax treatment. My concern is whether our tax laws accurately measure income and establish reasonable reporting obligations. From what I’ve encountered professionally, the current system creates serious problems in both areas.

The Fundamental Problem With Gambling Taxes

Under federal law, recreational gambling winnings are reported as income, while gambling losses are deducted separately as itemized deductions on Schedule A. This means a taxpayer generally must give up the standard deduction to benefit from their gambling losses.

Congress made the treatment more restrictive beginning in 2026. Under the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, amended IRC §165(d) limits deductible wagering losses to 90% of those losses, not exceeding wagering gains.

While there are bipartisan efforts to restore the full 100% deduction, I believe they overlook a much larger problem.

Even if taxpayers could deduct every dollar they lost, requiring those losses to be itemized deductions would still produce unfavorable results for many recreational gamblers.

Consider a single taxpayer earning $60,000 in wages during 2026. They have $2,000 in otherwise allowable itemized deductions and place sports wagers throughout the year, accumulating $20,000 in winnings and $20,000 in losses.

Their actual gambling profit is zero.

Federal tax calculationTaxable income
No gambling activity$43,900
Break-even gambling under current 90% rule$60,000
Break-even gambling if 100% deduction restored$58,000
Break-even gambling if gains and losses could be netted before AGI$43,900

Assumes the $20,000 represents gains from winning wagers after recovering the original stakes, with $20,000 in separate losing wagers. The taxpayer is single, has no other adjustments, and qualifies for the 2026 standard deduction of $16,100.

Even if Congress restores the full gambling loss deduction, this taxpayer has $14,100 more taxable income than someone with identical wages who never gambled.

I find that difficult to justify. For investments, qualifying capital gains and losses are generally netted before adjusted gross income, subject to their own limitations. Recreational gambling receives very different treatment, despite the same basic principle that a taxpayer’s overall financial result should matter.

There’s also a secondary consequence: reporting gambling winnings increases adjusted gross income, even when losses are subsequently deducted. That can affect income-based tax credits and other benefits.

Economist Karl Whelan examined this issue in a 2023 study published in the Journal of Gambling Studies. His research suggests that the itemization requirement disproportionately disadvantages lower- and middle-income bettors and may even create incentives for certain gamblers to increase their betting activity.

That seems particularly counterproductive if the policy objective is to discourage gambling.

Some States Make the Problem Considerably Worse

The federal treatment is only part of the issue. Several states, including Ohio, Connecticut, Illinois, and Indiana, generally don’t permit recreational gamblers to deduct gambling losses against their winnings.

These states ordinarily begin with federal adjusted gross income, which includes recreational gambling winnings before any federal itemized loss deduction.

Return to our taxpayer with $20,000 in winnings and $20,000 in losses. In a state that disallows gambling loss deductions, the full $20,000 can remain in the state income tax calculation despite the taxpayer breaking even.

Connecticut’s top marginal income tax rate reaches 6.99%, while Illinois imposes a flat 4.95% individual income tax. Depending on the taxpayer’s circumstances, state taxes attributable to gambling winnings can become substantial even when the year’s actual gambling result is zero.

I understand that states have different revenue needs and tax policies. However, taxing the winnings while disregarding the losses can produce a liability that’s difficult to reconcile with the taxpayer’s actual economic circumstances.

Most Taxpayers Don’t Understand the Reporting Requirements

In my experience, one of the biggest issues is that many recreational gamblers don’t report their winnings because they never receive Form W-2G. Some genuinely believe no form means no taxable income. Others know the sportsbook hasn’t issued a W-2G and deliberately leave those winnings off their tax returns, assuming the IRS won’t catch them.

The available research supports concerns about widespread misunderstanding.

A 2025 NerdWallet survey found that only 24% of surveyed sports bettors said they report betting proceeds as taxable income. The survey included 458 sports bettors and relied on self-reported answers, so it doesn’t establish an exact national noncompliance rate.

The IRS’s own enforcement history is also concerning. A September 2024 Treasury Inspector General audit identified 148,908 taxpayers who received Forms W-2G reporting more than $15,000 in gambling winnings per person during 2018–2020 but hadn’t filed federal tax returns.

Approximately 69% hadn’t even received an IRS delinquency notice as of March 2023. These are historical findings, and the IRS has since taken steps to address the problem, but they demonstrate significant gaps in enforcement even when third-party reporting existed.

For ordinary sports wagers that don’t trigger Form W-2G, there may be no corresponding transaction-specific information return automatically furnished to the IRS. The IRS can obtain additional records through lawful examination procedures, but that doesn’t resolve the inconsistency in routine reporting.

Our tax system depends heavily on voluntary compliance. When some taxpayers report everything and face substantial liabilities while others fail to report taxable winnings, confidence in the fairness of the system suffers.

Even Taxpayers Trying to Comply Face Difficulties

The other problem I regularly encounter is inadequate recordkeeping. Taxpayers who genuinely want to report their gambling activity correctly often haven’t maintained the detailed information needed to establish their winnings and losses.

Some sportsbooks and casinos provide annual win-loss statements, but these reports don’t necessarily contain everything needed for an accurate tax return. FanDuel, for example, explicitly states that its Player Activity Statement is not a tax document.

There are also different accounting methods depending on the type of gambling. IRS guidance has recognized session-based calculations for certain slot-machine activity, allowing gains and losses during a qualifying session to be considered together. Sports wagers, however, generally involve independent transactions and aren’t automatically eligible for the same treatment.

Michigan Revenue Administrative Bulletin 2022-22 explains these distinctions and acknowledges that gambling establishment statements may not independently establish a taxpayer’s complete wagering activity.

I find it unreasonable that taxpayers are expected to understand these technical distinctions without clearer guidance or comprehensive reporting from the operators maintaining their transaction records.

What Would Fairer Gambling Taxation Look Like?

I recognize that some policymakers may favor restrictive gambling taxation as a way to discourage participation. There are legitimate public-policy arguments behind that position. However, the research on itemization incentives suggests the resulting behavior may be more complicated than simply making gambling less attractive.

My proposed approach is relatively straightforward: allow recreational gamblers to calculate taxable gambling income using properly documented annual wagering gains reduced by wagering losses, limited to those gains, before adjusted gross income.

This would prevent gambling losses from offsetting wages, business income, investment gains, or other unrelated income. A taxpayer who lost money gambling would receive no deduction against those other income sources.

Someone who earned $10,000 in actual net gambling profit would report $10,000. Someone who broke even would report zero.

I would also support standardized annual reporting requirements that provide taxpayers with usable records of their winnings and losses, alongside more consistent enforcement of those obligations.

Current bipartisan proposals, including the FAIR BET Act, focus on restoring the 100% deduction. That may address the newest restriction, but it doesn’t resolve the underlying problems involving itemization, adjusted gross income, and states that disallow gambling losses.

Final Thoughts

I believe our tax system should measure income as accurately as reasonably possible, and I don’t see why recreational gambling should be treated so differently from other activities where gains and losses are considered together.

My concern is entirely about tax administration and fairness. I’m not advocating for gambling losses to offset unrelated income, nor am I suggesting that gambling profits should be exempt from taxation.

I believe taxpayers should be taxed on their actual economic gains, provided they can substantiate those amounts through reliable records. That approach would be easier to understand, more consistent with other areas of income taxation, and more practical to administer.

Until the rules change, taxpayers should understand that gambling winnings can be taxable even without Form W-2G, that losses require proper substantiation, and that federal and state treatment can differ substantially.

At Stronghold Tax Advisors, I help individuals understand complicated tax reporting obligations and evaluate how those rules affect their overall tax situations.

Last reviewed November 13, 2026. This article reflects the author’s professional opinions concerning gambling tax policy and provides general information about federal and state tax rules. It focuses on recreational gambling; professional gambling activities may receive different tax treatment. This material is not individualized tax or legal advice.

Levi King, Enrolled Agent

About the author

Levi King, EA

Enrolled Agent and Principal Tax Advisor, Stronghold Tax Advisors

Levi founded Stronghold Tax Advisors to change the way tax work gets done, with planning first, filing second, and a direct line to the person doing the work. He has prepared thousands of tax returns, advised hundreds of taxpayers on tax planning, and represented dozens of clients before the IRS. As an Enrolled Agent, he’s authorized by the IRS to represent taxpayers in every state, and he writes these insights to make complicated rules easier to act on.

More about Levi

Keep reading

All Tax Insights

Questions about your gambling income?

Book a free discovery call and we’ll look at how your winnings and losses should be reported and which records support them.

Book a Free Discovery Call